By Levi Sumagaysay, Cal Matters
Editor’s note This story was originally published Feb. 4 by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters at https://calmatters.org/subscribe-to-calmatters/.
•••
State Farm, the largest insurer for California homeowners, this week asked the state to approve “emergency” rate increases for insurance policy holders, saying the recent Los Angeles County fires have imperiled its finances.
The company wants an average 22% increase for homeowners and 15% for renters to help provide “emergency” cash infusions as it attempts to pay out claims. State Farm said it would issue refunds if the requests it made last year — 30% for homeowners, 52% for renters and 36% for condominium owners — get approved and are lower than the interim rates.
The state’s Insurance Department is investigating the company’s financial situation.
In a letter dated Feb. 3, State Farm CEO Dan Krause and other executives wrote to Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara that the company “needs your urgent assistance in the form of emergency interim approval of additional rate to help avert a dire situation for our customers and the insurance market in the state of California.”
State Farm has received more than 8,700 claims and paid more than $1 billion to its customers in the state as of Feb. 1, the executives said. “We know we will ultimately pay out significantly more, as these fires will collectively be the costliest in the history of the company,” they added.
The company has nearly 3 million policies in the state, including 1 million homeowner policies, the executives said. They mentioned that last year, credit-rating firm AM Best downgraded the credit rating for State Farm General, the California arm of the nationwide State Farm Group, because of its financial picture.
State Farm executives want the interim rates to be effective May 1, and referenced their pending rate requests from last year.
Also in their letter, they alluded to both their company’s financial position as well as the state insurance market’s ongoing struggles: “In addition to your other efforts, immediate approval of additional and appropriately supported rate… sends a strong message that the state is serious about reforming its insurance market and allowing insurers to collect sufficient premiums to protect Californians against the risk of loss to their homes.”
Lara’s plan to address insurance availability in the state took effect at the beginning of the year, just days before the L.A.-area fires.
It is widely expected to lead to significantly higher premium increases as the state allows insurers to include catastrophe modeling and the cost of reinsurance when setting their rates.
In response to State Farm’s new request, the department is scheduling a meeting of its rate-review experts, State Farm and Consumer Watchdog, which last year challenged the rate increases, insurance department spokesperson Gabriel Sanchez said. Department staff will then make an “urgent formal recommendation for action” to the commissioner, Sanchez said.
Carmen Balber, executive director of Consumer Watchdog, said her group has repeatedly asked State Farm for more information about its finances, including why its parent company can’t “step in” and help its California business.
Consumer Watchdog last year accused State Farm General of redirecting profit by buying reinsurance from its parent company, an allegation on which the company would not comment.
“Insurance Commissioner Lara must require State Farm to prove it needs this staggering increase,” Balber said.
TOP PHOTO CREDIT: Alekz Londos